The ultimate list of Halloween Nutter Butters! Awesome Halloween cookie decorating ideas that all start with a simple Nutter Butter. LOVE!

Anyone who follows me on Pinterest knows I have a slight obsession with Nutter Butters. Ok, a big obsession. I want to be that one weirdo who collects ALL THE NUTTER BUTTER IDEAS EVER, and it seems I’m off to a decent start. While Nutter Butter creativity isn’t limited to any particular season or holiday (thank goodness) ; ) there certainly seems to be a lot of Halloween Nutter Butters out there. I rounded up 24 awesome Halloween Nutter Butter ideas that cover everything from ghostly skeleton faces to spooky owls to creepy witches’ toes! Enjoy!!

1. Bat pop by Five Heart Home

2. Zombie eyeballs by Sweet Simple Stuff

3. Witches’ broomsticks by Party Pinching

4. Dracula by Kitchen Fun with My Three Sons

5. Frankenstein by Kitchen Fun with My Three Sons

6. Wolf man by Kitchen Fun with My Three Sons

7. Black cats by My Mommy Style

8. Witch fingers by Kitchen Concoctions

9. Mummy pop by Five Heart Home

10. Monster claws by Gourmet Mom on the Go

11. Ghosts by Momables

12. Graveyard pudding cups by Flour On My Face

13. Skulls by Party City

14. Spooky owls by Snack Works

15. Frankenstein by Everyday Dishes

16. Zombies by Party Pinching

17. Halloween masks by Crazy For Crust

18. Bats by Sweet Simple Stuff

19.Vampires by Snack Works

20. Graveyard brownies by Delightful Chaos

21. Creepy crawly bugs by Betty Crocker

22. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup bats by Totally The

23. Skulls by Hungry Happenings

24. Gruesome green toes by Taste of Home


Shop now for Halloween!